
Mayor Zohran Mamdani released a framework Tuesday for roughly 300 horse-carriage drivers whose industry the New York City Council voted in October to shut down by June 2028. The framework names a medallion buyback program, career training at LaGuardia Community College, and a feasibility study for electric carriages in Central Park. It does not include specific funding figures. The full transition plan is due April 1, 2027.
The bill, named after Romanch Mahajan—the 18-year-old tourist who died in June while trying to save his mother after she fell from a runaway carriage—will phase out licenses by May 31, 2028, and bar new ones the following day. Many drivers have worked in the trade for decades, and they say Tuesday’s framework still doesn’t answer what matters most to them: what their medallions are worth, what happens to their horses, and whether the training programs match the trade they’re losing.
The Horse Carriage Worker Industry Program, run by NYC Talent and the Department of Small Business Services through LaGuardia Community College, would offer about 200 workers career advisement, job training, entrepreneurship support, and tuition assistance. Deputy Mayor Julie Su said in a statement that the framework “reflects our commitment to supporting every New Yorker affected by this transition.” The administration said it would engage Transport Workers Union Local 100 at each step.
TWU Local 100 President John Samuelsen said that the framework does not close what the legislation leaves open. “The core problem remains,” Samuelsen said in a statement. “The City Council passed a horrifically flawed and unconstitutional anti-worker bill that abolishes an entire industry without any funding, mandates, or guarantees.” The union said it would file a federal lawsuit challenging the law’s legality when Mamdani signs it.
Christina Hansen has been a carriage driver for 20 years and is the shop steward for TWU Local 100. She said drivers have little faith that the city will follow through on the transition plan.
“It doesn’t protect the horses, it doesn’t protect the workers, and it doesn’t protect the medallion owners—who are also carriage drivers—because it just kicks it off to April,” Hansen said.
Hansen and the carriage drivers she represents are frustrated that the transition plan wasn’t included in the legislation before the council approved it.
“Why don’t you let the mayor come up with a plan, and then you put it into the amendments, and then you pass it. Like, put it into writing in the administrative code, make it a law, so you have to follow through,” Hansen said.
Other cities have paid out when they ended similar industries. When Málaga, Spain banned horse carriages in 2025, drivers received the equivalent of about $145,000 each, according to Animals 24-7, an animal welfare publication. And in 1974, as New York’s longshore industry declined, dockworkers were guaranteed annual compensation under a three-year contract, according to The New York Times. The New York bill includes no such compensation.
Ahmet Bilici, a driver who has invested 25 years in his business, doesn’t think the transition plan will adequately compensate him for his medallion, which he paid almost half a million dollars for.
“My last 25 years. Can you give it back to me? I worked 25 years, and then buy this medallion. And then you take it back. My age now is 25 years older than the beginning. How can I build again, buy the business, or something like this? Can I work the same way?” Bilici said.
Atakan Aktay, a driver since 2013 and owner of three medallions, is willing to compromise. He points to proposals to modernize the industry with low-speed electric vehicles. Aktay is also open to a buyout but is unsure whether older drivers can transition to an entirely new industry.
“I have my father-in-law working. He’s like 63 years old. And he doesn’t know what he’s gonna do. How can you learn? How can you teach an old dog new tricks?” Aktay said.
Drivers make between $65,000 and $85,000 a year, Samuelsen told The New York Times. The 68 New York City medallions are worth about $25 million, with drivers having paid as much as $400,000 per medallion, according to CBS News. Over 100 carriage horses will need care after the ban.
Hansen doesn’t think a new job will pay enough to support her five horses, and the ban doesn’t allow her to sell them to other carriage businesses.
“Even if they give me a job, it’s probably gonna be like a $22-an-hour job. I will not be able to afford to take care of [them] and my two other working horses. Nor will I be able to take care of my two retired horses that I currently pay board for upstate,” Hansen said. “So, that’s five horses they’re gonna make homeless.”